Advisory vs discretionary management

Advisory vs discretionary management

Choosing how you work with your wealth manager

Every relationship with a wealth manager rests on a question that has little to do with markets: how much do you want to decide yourself? Some people answer at once. Others have never been asked, and find their answer depends on how much time they want to dedicate, how strongly they hold their own views, and which decision is in front of them.

The industry frames this as advisory vs discretionary management, with execution-only as a third route. Below, we explain what each model means in practice at WELF, who each tends to suit, how clients combine them, and what happens when your circumstances change. We also set out the part that should never change, whichever model you choose: the standard of service around it.

What is the difference between advisory and discretionary management?

The foundation for both is the same: your investment objectives, which define your strategic investment goals.

In discretionary management, we start by defining your investment strategy together, built on your objectives and strategic goals. From there, we manage your portfolio on your behalf and make the day-to-day decisions, always within the guidelines you have approved.

Advisory management starts in the same place, with an investment strategy we agree together. From there, we give you specific recommendations and portfolio guidance, and you have the final say on any investment decision.

The guidelines in a discretionary mandate set the direction: your objectives, the level of risk you are prepared to take, any sectors or companies you want excluded, how much liquidity you need to keep available, etc. Within those limits, we handle execution, monitoring and adjustments. Advisory works similarly, but you are in the driving seat for every investment decision. We bring the ideas and a clear recommendation based on your objectives and the level of risk you are prepared to take; the final call is always yours. We then arrange execution.

There is a third model. With execution-only, you make the investment decision yourself, and we arrange execution through authorised third-party banks, brokers, custodians and platforms. It tends to suit clients who already know what they want to buy or sell, and who value direct control and speed.

Which model suits you?

The right model depends on which decisions you want to own. In our experience, four questions usually settle it.

How much time can you dedicate to your investments? A discretionary mandate asks for a handful of structured reviews a year. Advisory asks you to engage each time a decision comes up, which in volatile markets can be often.

How strong are your own views and how big is your interest in markets and investing? Many clients have deep knowledge of a sector, a region or an asset class, often from their own careers, and want to apply it. Advisory gives them a sparring partner with research behind every recommendation.  

How quickly should the portfolio respond? After a sharp market move, a discretionary portfolio can be rebalanced within the agreed guidelines. Under advisory, the same rebalance waits for your approval. That matters more if you travel often, run a business, or would simply rather not take investment calls on holiday.

Do you want your portfolio to be managed by investment professionals? Some clients are most comfortable with an outcome when an investment professional makes all the decisions within the agreed guidelines. Others prefer an investment professional as an advisor and experienced partner to provide them with investment ideas that fit their strategy but want to be in the driving seat and take the final decision. Neither preference is better than the other; they simply lead to different models.

None of these answers are permanent. The same person may want a hands-on role for one decade and full delegation in the next, or the reverse.

Can you combine models?

Yes. Our experience has shown that a combination of the three models is the best approach to achieving long-term investment goals.  

A common pattern is a discretionary diversified core for long-term growth and income managed by WELF. An advisory allocation for areas where the client wants to be actively involved, such as investments in specific asset classes like private markets, real estate or other alternative assets, but also in specific equity sectors for example. And an execution-only account for a concentrated holding or for personal investing. Shares in a company someone founded often sit in that last group, because the decision to hold or sell them is personal as much as financial.

Blends also follow families. One family member may delegate fully while another prefers to approve each decision, and a younger member may start in an advisory arrangement to learn how decisions are made before taking on more. The models sit side by side, so the overall picture stays in one place rather than splitting across separate relationships.

Prime standards in every model

Whichever model you choose at WELF, the service around it is held to the same prime standard. Taking full control over investment decisions, or handing over day to day decisions, should never mean accepting a lesser service.

In practice, that covers:

  • Due diligence on the products, banks, custodians, and platforms we work with
  • Tailor-made investment strategy
  • Portfolio monitoring and clear reporting on your whole position
  • Risk notifications and corresponding advises
  • Direct access to your dedicated adviser, whether you delegate everything or decide everything by yourself
  • Careful execution of every instruction, through authorised counterparties
  • A regulated framework for every account, with assets held by authorised third parties

What the model changes is who makes the day to day investment decision. In execution-only, for example, the investment decision is yours. If you would ever like our view before you act, your adviser is a conversation away, and that decision can move into an advisory arrangement. The attention, care and speed of service you receive stay exactly where they are.

With WELF, that means the same reporting you receive, the same responsiveness from your adviser, and the review of your position under each arrangement, whether your wealth sits in one model or across all three.

How does switching between models work?

You change the agreement, not the relationship. Your goals, your history and what we already know about you stay in place, so you never have to explain your situation twice.

The reasons to switch are usually personal, but often related to the time you can dedicate to your investments. The sale of a business, a move to a new jurisdiction, a new venture that absorbs your time, a change in health, or the next generation taking on responsibility can all shift how involved you want to be. It works in both directions: someone stepping back from a demanding career often wants more say in their portfolio, not less.

In practice, a switch means updating your agreement. When additionally, life circumstances change, updating your investment objectives, risk circumstances, etc. and agreeing how existing positions move across will be discussed.

Frequently asked questions

Do I give up control with a discretionary mandate? You delegate day to day decisions only, but you keep control of the direction. You approve the guidelines we work within, review results with your adviser, and can change the guidelines or move to another model whenever your circumstances change.

Can I exclude sectors or set limits in a discretionary portfolio? Yes. Restrictions are possible and part of the investment guidelines. Typical examples are excluding particular sectors or companies, capping the size of any single position, or keeping a set level of liquidity available.

Who holds my assets? In every model, your assets are held in your account by authorised third-party banks and custodians. The model changes who makes the investment decisions, not where your assets are kept.

How often should I review which model I am in? At least once a year as part of your regular review of the investment strategy and guidelines, and whenever something significant changes in your life, your family or your business.

Where to start

The debate over advisory vs discretionary management tends to treat the choice as a fixed label. Yet, here's a question you can answer today: which decisions do you want to own right now? With your response, the model follows. Review your answer again when your life changes, and you may have a different one. In our experience, combining models has shown to be the best approach in achieving long-term investment goals.

What should stay constant is everything around the decision: the research, the reporting, the care in execution, and an adviser who knows your story. That is the standard we hold in every model.

If you would like to think through which mix fits your situation today, your WELF adviser is the place to start, or speak with our team to begin the conversation.

This article is general information, not personalised investment, legal or tax advice.

‍

Your WELF Journey
‍Starts Here.
Begin your journey by contacting our dedicated team. Where your ambitions are listened to and understood.
Book a Private Consultation